Open multiple files with the same file name
Allow excel to open files with the same name but different location at the same time
Colin Cox
shared this idea
Thanks for your suggestion! Unfortunately we will not be able to address this in the near future. We’ll keep tracking the voting.
The reason you can’t have 2 workbooks open with the same name is due to the way that linked workbooks are managed. If you have multiple workbooks open and you create a link between them, Excel shows the filename of the linked file. If there are 2 workbooks with the same name, then the formula would be ambiguous. You can read more about how Excel manages external links here – https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/help/328440/description-of-link-management-and-storage-in-excel.
4 comments
-
Anonymous
commented
Agree; I have been opening same-filenames in Lotus for almost 30 years. Example: A:\ floppy and C:\ hard drive was the original task. Why do you think/guess Excel disallows? To keep users from confusing themselves about where they are? Or a legit programming reason?
-
Roy
commented
Yeah. This is criminal.
Fix whatever compromise you made 30 years ago.
Like... open the file but keep track of it by a unique name you assign right then, analogous to database folks assinging every record a unique identifier, then letting you think you are assigning a unique identifier when it's really second level, but now you can change it freely instead of it being permanent. Well, once upon a time. Advance to at least that years old idea!
-
Anonymous
commented
I agree. I have wanted this ever since I switched from Lotus 1-2-3 to Excel (1994?)
-
Harlan Grove
commented
I can guess why Excel works the way it does, but Excel has never allowed C:\A\X.XLSX and C:\B\X.XLSX to be open at the same time in the same Excel instance. Excel may be the ONLY Windows program which can have multiple files open at the same time but not handle files in different drives and/or directories with the same base filename.
Time for Excel to grow up.
FWIW, Lotus 1-2-3 and Quattro Pro allowed this as far back as 1989. LibreOffice Calc allows it today.