Feedback by UserVoice

How can we improve Excel for Windows (Desktop Application)?

Power Query - cache shared nodes

Update Power Query in Excel to take advantage of caching in cases where a parent node refers to a child node that has already been refreshed (as exists in Power BI desktop today).

This issue creates significant performance problems with refresh times when creating highly interdependent financial and operational models. This is a show stopper from a usability and customer acceptance standpoint.

1,977 votes
Sign in
(thinking…)
Password icon
Signed in as (Sign out)

We’ll send you updates on this idea

Josh Blackman shared this idea  ·   ·  Flag idea as inappropriate…  ·  Admin →

293 comments

Sign in
(thinking…)
Password icon
Signed in as (Sign out)
Submitting...
  • Anonymous commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    To clarify... If I purchases Office 2019 today it would include the enhancement (or is that post July too)? Also, to confirm, there are no plans to introduce the enhancement to the add-on for any version prior to 2019?

  • Sifar commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Hi Josh, when is this solution going to be implemented for Excel 2016? It defeats the purpose of using Power query. Even with a 50k file transformed in Power Query, it takes >24 hours to load data to Data Model. This is a huge drawback!

    Is there a workaround to improve Power Query Refresh on referenced queries and the avoid formula firewall issue?

  • Ed Hansberry commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    @masterv - it depends on your data sources and how your queries are structured. Suggest you ask in the MSTechCommunity forums for assistance/advice on optimizing. Cached nodes didn't improve query performance in general, it stopped Excel from rerunning the same queries over and over if they were called multiple times in a model, instead calling them once and reusing the data if it was called again

  • Ed Hansberry commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    @Margaret - as per the Excel team comment below, Office 2019 has this feature, so any issues you are experiencing with long runtimes for queries would be unrelated to cached nodes.

  • Margaret F. Barr commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    I don't have e 365, I have MS Office Pro Plus 2019, and am leaning Power Query. The length of time for refresh is terrible. Not everyone had the internet connections to do 365. I thought 2019 would be the saving grace...NOT so far. Please do something. I have been on the MS Power Query Forum about this, and there is no resolution.

  • AdminExcel Team [MSFT] (Product Owner, Office.com) commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Hi all,

    Just to clarify, the fix will be available for Office 365 customers starting from July fork (build 16.0.10726.*) and for Office 2019 perpetual customers.

    The fix is not be available for Office 2016 perpetual customers, or for customers running Office 2013 or Office 2010.

    - Excel Team

  • Alan commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Hi Excel Team,

    This is perfect news, thank you so much for taking our wishes in consideration and rolling it out!

    Will an update also be available for earlier versions, e.g. Office 2013 Pro Plus?

    Thank you and kind regards,
    Alan

  • Ed Hansberry commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    This was released to the general public in office 365 in Feb/Mar 2018. It will improve old queries. You don't have to rewrite, but it will only improve some queries where Excel was going back to the server repeatedly for the same info because the data was used in multiple places. There are tons of scenarios where this won't help at all as Excel was never calling for the data multiple times in the first place.

    I have not been able to find out if this made it into Excel 2019 though. That is based on 1803, so kind of border line as to whether the feature is there or not, but it is definitely in any Office 365 for Windows build out now. Even deferred channel should have it has that is only 6 months behind current versions.

  • Jim Kemp commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    There seems to be some confusion over whether this improvement is in "mainstream" production for all users or just for "Office Insiders". I, myself (not an "Office Insider"), have not seen the kinds of significant improvements people have been posting about. Is it possible that a) the improvement is not yet released to the general public or, b) the improvement only affects power query files built after the improvement was released?

  • Anonymous commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    I am currently using version 16.0.8431.2366 in my organisation... does this include the related improvement? I'm trying to rule this out as a performance issue with my queries.

  • Anonymous commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    It took me 20-25 mins to refresh in Excel 2016 as compared to less than 1min in Power BI Desktop!

  • Ed Hansberry commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    This was rolled out early 2018 for office 365 and I believe was included in office 2019 when it shipped

  • Andrey Minakov commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Hi All! I watched trace log of the version, and have to say that a number of exceptions can be found in the logs.

    All of them a happens when there are operations with files of different kind. So far I see exceptions while reading excel files and in case of using cash of web-requests. I think exceptions a thrown during using the cash, because, when I refresh a multi-step query in PQ UI, the exception happens only after the second launch of a function, which makes a web request. Again - all the exceptions can be seen only in trace logs, while you get correct data in result of request. BUT - these exceptions defenitely slow down the work - there are a number of them, and PQ ignores Table.Buffer when it see such exceptions (I can see that in the logs as well).
    The error message is:
    Exception:
    ExceptionType: System.IO.EndOfStreamException, mscorlib, Version=4.0.0.0, Culture=neutral, PublicKeyToken=b77a5c561934e089
    Message: Чтение после конца потока невозможно.
    StackTrace:
    в System.IO.__Error.EndOfFile()
    в System.IO.BinaryReader.FillBuffer(Int32 numBytes)
    в System.IO.BinaryReader.ReadInt64()
    в Microsoft.Mashup.EngineHost.Services.DiskPersistentCache.PersistentDictionary.<>c__DisplayClass2c.<ReadBucket>b__2b()
    в Microsoft.Mashup.EngineHost.Services.FileSystemAccessHelper.<>c__DisplayClass4.<IgnoringAccessExceptions>b__3()
    в Microsoft.Mashup.EngineHost.Services.FileSystemAccessHelper.TryIgnoringAccessExceptions[T](Func`1 func, IEvaluationConstants evaluationConstants, T& result, Exception& accessException)

  • Adam Bender commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    I have noticed significant speed improvements since the changes recently. Using Win 10 64 bit, Office 365 64 bit, connecting to a MS SQL server.

    Previewing or making changes to a table with 33M rows and around 50 columns was nearly impossible before, or it would take 5 minutes per step. Now it takes around 20-30 seconds to get the preview and only a few seconds per step.

    Huge improvement.

  • James commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Just wanted to follow up on this to see if there has been any progress with this update? The last update from the Excel Team was early in July. I also see that there has been no updates to PQ for Excel 2013 since July; whereas PowerBI has received numerous updates. Will these recent updates be flowed through to Power Query?

  • Andrey Minakov commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    But it would be definitely interesting to understand, why do you make 2 equal request, and not just 1? Of course is much better in comparison with the current standard release, where you make from 4 to 6 equal requests, but why you decided to make 2 instead of 1?

  • Andrey Minakov commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Guys, you definitely have improved web requests, thanks for that! At least from that point of view Excel now works better than PBI Desktop ;-). So now, if I make any number of references to a web query in Excel (loaded to a model, of course), there is NO any additional requests to a web source while refreshing the model. And in PBIDesctop I still have additional requests per reference. Just cool for Excel users!

  • Anonymous commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    I think this is obvious to anyone using PQ along with PowerPivot, but let's just make this distinction really clear:
    1- If you are not using PowerPivot, always make sure your table is not loading to the data model ("load to" window)
    2- If you are using PowerPivot, make sure you ONLY load to the data model the queries that you absolutely need.

    In my case, with a large, complex data set, I made sure to create data model specific final queries where the last step was to "Remove other columns". That serves as a gatekeeper to stop any unnecessary columns from taking up space in my data model.

    Another tip for PowerPivot users: download the PowerPivot Utilities add-in to measure the weight of each column, usage of your columns and metrics, etc. It is a fantastic tool for optimizations.

← Previous 1 3 4 5 14 15

Feedback and Knowledge Base